A new episode of Oxygen’s Snapped: Killer Moms will revisit the case of Sarah Hartsfield, the Chambers County woman sentenced to life in prison for the insulin-related death of her husband, Joseph Hartsfield.
KPRC 2 reporter Bryce Newberry was interviewed for the episode, which is scheduled to air Sunday, Nov. 22, at 6 p.m. on the Oxygen Network.
The episode, titled “Sarah Hartsfield,” will examine the case and the events surrounding Joseph Hartsfield’s death in January 2023.
Viewers who miss Sunday’s premiere can catch reruns throughout the week on Oxygen. The episode is also expected to become available on Peacock approximately one week after its initial broadcast.
While the television episode revisits the case, Hartsfield is also challenging her murder conviction.
Last month, appellate attorney Timothy Hootman filed a brief with the Texas First Court of Appeals, asking the court to overturn Hartsfield’s conviction and order a new trial.
In the filing, Hootman argued the trial court improperly allowed jurors to hear extensive evidence about alleged misconduct unrelated to Joseph Hartsfield’s death.
That evidence included allegations that Hartsfield attempted to burn down her first husband’s home, burned down a family home inherited by her brother, shot and killed her former fiancé David Bragg in Minnesota and arranged a murder-for-hire plot targeting the new wife of her third ex-husband, Christopher Donohue.
Hootman argued those allegations were not sufficiently similar to the insulin-related killing and that prosecutors failed to establish how each incident was relevant to the murder case.
He also argued the evidence could have distracted jurors from the central issues they were tasked with deciding.
Additionally, Hootman challenged the medical evidence presented at trial, arguing it did not establish that Hartsfield administered the insulin that led to her husband’s death.
He took issue with prosecutors’ reliance on what he characterized as asking jurors to “use your reason and your logic and your common sense” rather than presenting medical evidence directly establishing that Hartsfield administered the insulin.
Prosecutors have not yet filed their response to Hartsfield’s appeal.
Prosecutor Mallory Vargas requested an extension, citing the extensive records in the case and preparation for multiple felony trials.
The court granted the extension, giving the state until Dec. 18 to file its response.
Hartsfield is currently incarcerated at the Texas Department of Criminal Justice’s Murray Unit in Gatesville, a women’s facility that houses more than 1,200 inmates.