DENVER — A state hearing officer has dismissed what is believed to be the first complaint filed under Colorado’s 2024 deepfake law. The ruling found that an AI-generated video lampooning one of the main legislative proponents of the recently passed Proposition NN tax hike is satire and parody, thus protected by the First Amendment.
In a 27-page initial decision issued Nov. 19, Secretary of State hearing officer Macon Cowles found “as a matter of law that the video is both a parody and a satire and that it cannot reasonably be understood to describe actual facts about Sen. Kipp or actual events in which she took part.”
State Sen. Cathy Kipp, a Fort Collins Democrat, filed the complaint against Independence Institute* over a video showing an AI version of her as a grocery cashier. In the video she pockets a customer’s $50 in change under a “new policy” to help educate children. The video followed Kipp’s April remarks on the Senate floor, as reported by CBS News Colorado. She said asking voters to let the state keep Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights (TABOR) refunds wasn’t a tax increase, describing it as asking “can we keep the money you have already paid in taxes.”
Proposition NN, which Kipp sponsored through Senate Bill 26-135, raises the TABOR revenue cap and redirects refund dollars largely to K-12 education, at least for the first decade. State analysts estimated it would eliminate $851 million in refunds through 2028. the measure passed by roughly 57% on the Nov. 3 ballot.
The deepfake law requires a disclaimer at least as large as the biggest text in the video. The Institute’s small-print version read: “AI generated content because who gets a human cashier these days?” The Secretary of State’s Elections Division prosecuted the case, arguing the video was “straight-faced” advocacy, not satire.
Defending the Institute was David Lane, one of the best-known civil rights and free-speech litigators in the state. He’s also no stranger to defending the Institute. He represented the free-market think tank in a 2013 federal trial over whether Colorado’s limits on per-signature pay for petition circulators violated the First Amendment.
Cowles sided with Lane’s client on every major point. “No store operates that way, and no cashier announces a theft as store policy,” he wrote. He added that “Deadpan delivery is one of satire’s oldest methods.”
Cowles also rejected the argument that a policy organization can’t produce satire: “the First Amendment protection for satire is not available only to publications that specialize in it.” He compared the video to a political cartoon and quoted the U.S. Supreme Court in Hustler v. Falwell: “The art of the cartoonist is often not reasoned or evenhanded, but slashing and one-sided.”
On the claim that the video was political advocacy rather than humor, Cowles wrote, “Advocacy is the purpose while satire is the creator’s method.” If advocacy disqualified speech from the law’s satire exemption, he wrote, the exemption “would lose its function as a First Amendment protection.”
He also rejected the argument that only content that “clearly” qualifies as satire is protected. He cited Chief Justice John Roberts: “Where the First Amendment is implicated, the tie goes to the speaker, not the censor.”
Cowles said an administrative tribunal can’t rule on the law’s constitutionality. However, he pointed to Kohls v. Bonta, in which a federal judge struck down California’s similar labeling requirement. That judge found a label that large “drowns out” a parody’s message.
The decision is not yet final. The Elections Division has 30 days to file exceptions with the Deputy Secretary of State, who may also review the ruling on his own. As the original complainant, Kipp may seek judicial review in district court once agency remedies are exhausted.
The decision is available here. And the video in question is available here.
* Complete Colorado is published by Independence Institute, the respondent in this case.
The post ‘Deepfake’ complaint against Colorado think tank tossed out appeared first on Complete Colorado.